Let Us Give Thanks to the Lord Our God

Last Monday at Pub Theology, we took up this question: Is the kind of thanksgiving we share around the dinner table in late November – the kind our secular culture celebrates - the same as the kind of thanksgiving we do in church?

Some folks shared that those thanksgivings we share around the dinner table can feel like a performance. Maybe you try to think of exactly the right thing to say, something suitably substantial and impressive. Maybe we hesitate to express our thanks for the small and supposedly insignificant things: a new pair of socks, a good grade on a paper, an afternoon in the park. Others mentioned that when gratitude is turned into an expectation, it turns into something other than true thanksgiving – something more like a transaction.

In the Gospel for Thanksgiving Day, we read the story of the ten lepers. On the road to Jerusalem, Jesus encounters a group of ten lepers. He heals them, but only one turns back to thank Jesus and to worship God. The one who turns back is a Samaritan. As a leper and a Samaritan, he’s an outsider twice over. Of all the people in this story, he has the least to offer in thanksgiving. His gratitude can never be a transaction. When you know you can't earn your way or buy your way to anything, perhaps you can more readily recognize a gift when it's given.

In the Eucharist, we give thanks for the ultimate gift that we can’t earn and can’t buy. The word “Eucharist” itself means "thanksgiving." Every Sunday. the celebrant says, "Let us give thanks to the Lord our God," and we answer, "It is right to give God thanks and praise." In church, thanksgiving isn't a performance. It's our response to what God has already done for us, and what God has done is something that we could never do for ourselves. At the altar, we come back like the Samaritan, with empty hands and hearts full of praise and wonder.

I hope that wherever you spend Thanksgiving, and whoever you spend it with, you enjoy the holiday weekend. I also hope that you’ll spend some time at the place where we meet Jesus, and where we give thanks for what we have been most freely given: God’s grace. And if you'd like to have more conversations like this, join us at Pub Theology on Monday nights: 7 PM at the Yankee Doodle Tap Room. Come and see for yourself!

Yours in Christ,

Kara